How long should I stay in New York for buying to make sense?

Most New York buyers need to stay between 6 and 10 years depending on location and costs.

Rent vs Buy Calculator – NYC, Long Island & Westchester

Q: Is it better to rent or buy in NYC?

Buying in NYC usually makes sense for long-term residents due to high prices and closing costs.

Q: Is it better to rent or buy on Long Island?

Buying often makes sense on Long Island for residents planning to stay long-term, especially families.

Q: Should I rent or buy in Westchester County?

Renting offers flexibility in Westchester, while buying can build equity over time despite higher property taxes.

This New York rent vs buy calculator helps renters and home buyers compare the true cost of renting versus buying in NYC, Long Island, and Westchester County. Because New York has higher rents, prices, and property taxes than most states, a localized rent vs buy analysis is essential.

New York Rent vs Buy Calculator

Monthly Rent ($) Annual Rent Increase (%)

Home Purchase Price ($) Down Payment (%)

Mortgage Interest Rate (%) Years You Plan to Stay

Your Rent vs Buy Comparison

How the Rent vs Buy Calculator Works

Renting Costs Include:

Monthly rent payments
Annual rent increases (higher in NYC & suburbs)
No equity accumulation

Buying Costs Include:

Mortgage payments and interest
Property taxes (especially high in LI & Westchester)
Insurance, maintenance, and repairs
Closing costs

Rent vs Buy in NYC

In New York City, high purchase prices and closing costs mean buying usually makes sense only for long-term residents. However, rapid rent growth can tilt the decision toward buying for those planning to stay.

Most NYC buyers reach a rent vs buy break-even point after 8–10 years, depending on neighborhood and mortgage rates.

Rent vs Buy on Long Island

On Long Island, limited rental inventory and strong demand for single-family homes often make buying attractive for families and commuters planning to stay long-term.

Higher property taxes, especially in Nassau County
More space and long-term stability
Typical break-even: 6–8 years

Rent vs Buy in Westchester County

Westchester County combines proximity to NYC with strong school districts and high property taxes. Renting works short-term, but buying can build significant equity over time.

Among the highest property taxes in NY
Strong appreciation in desirable towns
Typical break-even: 7–9 years

Should You Rent or Buy in New York?

Renting May Be Better If:

You expect to move within a few years
You want flexibility for career changes
Mortgage rates are unfavorable

Buying May Be Better If:

You plan to stay long-term
You want to hedge against rising rents
You value building equity in NY real estate

New York Rent vs Buy FAQs

Is it better to rent or buy in NYC?

Buying usually makes sense in NYC for long-term residents due to high closing costs.

Is it better to rent or buy on Long Island?

Buying often makes sense for Long Island residents planning to stay long-term.

Should I rent or buy in Westchester County?

Renting offers flexibility, while buying can build equity despite higher taxes.

How long do I need to stay for buying to make sense?

Most New York buyers need to stay between 6–10 years depending on location.

Get a Personalized NY Rent vs Buy Analysis

Receive a custom breakdown based on your neighborhood and goals.